Public accountability

Agenda items.Votes explained.

I will use this page to discuss Palo Verde Community College District agenda items, record how I voted, and explain the reasons for my decisions.

May 12, 2026Agenda item 12.4Vote: NO

CircleIn Agreement

I voted NO because I had concerns about student privacy, data security, and how student information would be retained and protected under the agreement.

April 14, 2026Agenda item 12.10Vote: NO

Revised/New Management Job Descriptions.

Voted NO on a package of new and revised management job descriptions. I believed Palo Verde College already had too many management positions and that resources should be prioritized toward direct student services, instruction, access, and student success.

March 10, 2026Agenda item 11.2Vote: NO on each contract

Ger Xiong and Irma Gonzalez Employment Contracts

I voted NO on each contract because I believed the salaries were too high for the positions and the duties outlined. I voted on principle, exercising my independent judgment as a board member rather than voting for the sake of unity.

My Voting Record

My YES and NO votes.

Recorded votes from March 2026 onward, checked against the District’s posted minutes on September 16, 2026. Consent items approved together are listed under their single recorded motion. Recusals and votes not recorded are shown in the Board record below.

September 8, 2026 minutes are not yet posted. That meeting’s votes will be added when the record can be verified.

View the Board’s collective voting record

August 28, 2026

Agenda item	Item / motion	My vote
1.4	APPROVAL OF AGENDA	YES
2.1	APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT	NO
2.2	APPROVAL OF SUPPLEMENTAL PAY – RYAN COPPLE	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	My vote
1.3	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.2	Release a classified administratorClosed-session action reported under this item.	NO
4.3	APPROVAL OF OPEN SESSION AGENDA	YES
8.12	APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT - JULY & AUGUST 2026	YES
8.14	Consent agenda — 8.1, 8.2, 8.3, 8.4, 8.5, 8.6, 8.7, 8.8, 8.9, 8.10, 8.11, 8.13 Items included in this single consent vote 8.1 — APPROVAL OF JUNE 9, 2026, REGULAR MEETING MINUTES 8.2 — APPROVAL OF JUNE 23, 2026, SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES 8.3 — APPROVAL OF TEMPORARY PART-TIME FACULTY FOR FALL 2026 8.4 — RATIFICATION OF WORK ORDER AGREEMENT WITH TK ELEVATOR CORPORATION FOR WATER DAMAGE REPAIRS AT THE NEEDLES EDUCATIONAL CENTER 8.5 — APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH JEREMY JONES 8.6 — APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH KYLE CRIDER 8.7 — APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH ALCOVE INSIGHTS, INC. 8.8 — APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH AG DATA SOLUTIONS LLC 8.9 — APPROVAL OF STUDENT ATHLETIC INSURANCE COVERAGE 8.10 — APPROVAL OF VOLUNTEERS FOR ACADEMIC YEAR 2026-2027 8.11 — APPROVAL OF PART-TIME TEMPORARY STUDENT WORKERS FOR SUMMER 2026 SEMESTER 8.13 — APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH PAUL TRAN	YES
9.1	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT REGARDING THE PVC PEER ONLINE COURSE REVIEW (POCR) PROJECT FOR ACADEMIC YEAR 2026-2027	YES
9.2	APPROVAL OF COLLEGE AND CAREER ACCESS PATHWAYS (CCAP) PARTNERSHIP AGREEMENT WITH PALO VERDE UNIFIED SCHOOL DISTRICT	YES
9.3	APPROVAL OF EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY PLAN ANNUAL CERTIFICATION	YES
9.4	TITLE IX SEX DISCRIMINATION REPORT	YES
9.5	APPROVAL OF STUDENT TRAVEL	YES
9.6	APPROVAL OF OUT-OF-DISTRICT CLINICAL SITE PLACEMENTS	YES
9.7	DECLARATION OF SURPLUS PROPERTY AND AUTHORIZATION FOR THE SALE OF A DISTRICT VEHICLE	YES
9.8	RATIFICATION OF ORDER FORM NO. CC-002 AND AGREEMENT WITH MODERN CAMPUS USA INC.	YES
9.9	APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH P2C SOLUTIONS, LLC	YES
9.10	APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH TYLER NGUYEN	YES
9.11	APPROVAL OF CONSULTANT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH THERESA BECKER	YES
9.12	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH FERRILLI FOR CORE SYSTEM ADMINISTRATION SERVICES	YES
9.13	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH FERRILLI FOR FLEXPERT TECHNOLOGY CONSULTING SERVICES	YES
9.14	APPROVAL OF PROFESSIONAL SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH ROVING SPORTS MEDICINE PROFESSIONALS FOR ATHLETIC TRAINING SERVICES	YES
9.15	RATIFICATION OF EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT FOR INTERIM ASSISTANT SUPERINTENDENT/VICE PRESIDENT OF INSTRUCTION AND STUDENT SERVICES	YES
9.16	RATIFICATION OF EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENT FOR INTERIM ASSISTANT SUPERINTENDENT/VICE PRESIDENT OF ADMINISTRATIVE SERVICES AND COLLEGE ADVANCEMENT	YES
9.17	APPROVAL OF AUTHORIZED AGENTS AND RCOE CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURES FOR PVCCD	YES
9.18	CONSIDERATION OF APPROVAL OF THE ABSENCE OF TRUSTEE ANGEL RAMIREZ FROM THE JUNE 9, 2026, REGULAR MEETING OF THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES	NO

Agenda item	Item / motion	My vote
1.4	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.1	Approve ACCT to conduct the permanent Superintendent/President search and authorize the agreementClosed-session action reported under this item.	YES
4.1	Appoint Ed Knudson as Interim Superintendent/PresidentClosed-session action reported under this item.	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	My vote
1.4	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.1	Direct Stephanie Slagan to assume Acting Superintendent/President responsibilitiesClosed-session action reported under this item.	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	My vote
1.3	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.2	Terminate the Superintendent/President without cause under Article 10D of his contractClosed-session action reported under this item.	YES
4.3	APPROVAL OF OPEN SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.4	APPROVAL OF MARCH 10, 2026, REGULAR MEETING MINUTES	YES
11.8	Consent agenda — 11.1, 11.2, 11.3, 11.4, 11.5, 11.6, 11.7 Items included in this single consent vote 11.1 — APPROVAL OF CURRICULUM ITEMS 11.2 — APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT - APRIL 2026 11.3 — APPROVAL OF PART-TIME TEMPORARY STUDENT WORKERS FOR SPRING 2026 SEMESTER 11.4 — APPROVAL OF CONCURRENT ENROLLMENT PATHWAY AGREEMENT WITH GRAND CANYON UNIVERSITY 11.5 — APPROVAL OF EDUCATIONAL ALLIANCE PARTICIPANT AGREEMENT WITH GRAND CANYON UNIVERSITY 11.6 — APPROVAL OF THE REVISED 2026–2027 PROTECH ACADEMIC CALENDARS FOR CTE FACULTY 11.7 — APPROVAL OF REVISED ACADEMIC CALENDARS – FALL 2026 AND SPRING 2027	YES
12.1	Elect Gloria Copple as Board President for 2026	YES
12.2	Elect Jon McNeil as Board Vice President for 2026	YES
12.3	Elect Scott Dean as Board Clerk for 2026	YES
12.4	Appoint Brad Arneson as Riverside County Committee on School District Organization representative for 2026	YES
12.5	APPROVAL OF AUTHORIZED AGENTS AND RCOE CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURES FOR PVCCD	YES
12.6	APPROVAL OF RESOLUTION NO. 04.14.26-11.6 RECOGNIZING FACULTY APPRECIATION WEEK: MAY 4–8, 2026	YES
12.7	APPROVAL OF RESOLUTION NO. 04.14.26-11.7 RECOGNIZING CLASSIFIED SCHOOL EMPLOYEE WEEK: MAY 17–23, 2026	YES
12.8	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDA OF UNDERSTANDING BETWEEN PALO VERDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT AND PALO VERDE COLLEGE FACULTY ASSOCIATION, CTA/NEA	YES
12.9	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDUM OF UNDERSTANDING WITH PALO VERDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE ASSOCIATION FOR EXTRA DUTY ASSIGNMENT (MICHAEL CALABRESE – AWS CERTIFICATION)	YES
12.10	APPROVAL OF REVISED/NEW MANAGEMENT JOB DESCRIPTIONS	NO
12.11	APPROVAL OF SOLE SOURCE AGREEMENT WITH EDUCATION MANAGEMENT SOLUTIONS, LLC FOR THE SIMULATIONIQ ONE ROOM SYSTEM	YES
12.12	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH MESA ENERGY SYSTEMS, INC. FOR THE NEEDLES CENTER BUILDING MANAGEMENT SYSTEM UPGRADE	YES
12.13	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH GRAND RIVER SOLUTIONS, INC.	YES
12.14	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH RECORDS CONSULTANTS, INC. FOR COLLEGE-WIDE PHYSICAL FIXED ASSET INVENTORY SERVICES	YES
12.15	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH FOSTER & FOSTER CONSULTING ACTUARIES, INC. FOR GASB 74/75 ACTUARIAL VALUATION SERVICES	YES
12.16	SECOND READ AND APPROVAL OF BOARD POLICIES	YES
12.17	DISMISSAL OF LEGAL COUNSEL SERVICES WITH ATKINSON, ANDELSON, LOYA, RUUD & ROMO (AALRR)	YES
12.18	APPROVAL OF ABSENCE FOR TRUSTEE ANGEL RAMIREZ - FEBRUARY 10, 2026	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	My vote
1.3	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.2	Issue a March 15 notice to the Assistant SuperintendentClosed-session action reported under this item.	YES
4.3	APPROVAL OF OPEN SESSION AGENDA	YES
4.4	APPROVAL OF FEBRUARY 10, 2026, REGULAR MEETING MINUTES	YES
10.6	Consent agenda — 10.1, 10.2, 10.3, 10.4, 10.5 Items included in this single consent vote 10.1 — APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT - MARCH 2026 10.2 — APPROVAL OF VOLUNTEER FOR ACADEMIC YEAR 2025-2026 10.3 — APPROVAL OF PART-TIME TEMPORARY STUDENT WORKERS FOR SPRING 2026 SEMESTER 10.4 — APPROVAL OF ENERGY SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH CLIMATEC 10.5 — APPROVAL OF THE 2026–2027 PROTECH ACADEMIC CALENDARS FOR CTE FACULTY	YES
11.1	APPROVAL OF FACULTY TENURE AND TENURE-TRACK STATUS	YES
11.2	Separate the six educational administrator contracts for individual votes	YES
11.2	Approve the employment contract for Sandra "Sam" Robinson, Dean of Instruction.	YES
11.2	Approve the employment contract for Ger Xiong, Dean of Student Services.	NO
11.2	Approve the employment contract for Irma Gonzalez, Associate Dean of Counseling.	NO
11.2	Approve the employment contract for Ryan Copple, Athletic Director.	YES
11.2	Approve the employment contract for Jaclyn Randall, Dean of Needles Center.	YES
11.2	Approve the employment contract for Omar Pena, Director of EOPS/CARE/NEXTUP.	YES
11.3	APPROVAL OF EMPLOYMENT CONTRACT FOR EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATOR	YES
11.4	APPROVAL OF REVISED MANAGEMENT JOB DESCRIPTION	YES
11.6	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT (MOA) BETWEEN THE PALO VERDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE ASSOCIATION AND THE PALO VERDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT – EXTRA DUTY COMPENSATION FOR PART-TIME UNIT MEMBER PARTICIPATION IN SENATE EQUIVALENCY HEARINGS	YES
11.7	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT BETWEEN THE PALO VERDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE ASSOCIATION AND THE PALO VERDE COMMUNITY COLLEGE DISTRICT – SPECIAL EXTRA DUTY ASSIGNMENT: SENATE HUB DESIGNER	YES
11.8	APPROVAL OF 2025–2026 FIRST PRINCIPAL (P1) APPORTIONMENT REVENUE ADJUSTMENTS	YES
11.9	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH CAMBRIDGE WEST PARTNERSHIP, LLC FOR 5-YEAR CAPITAL OUTLAY PLAN AND SPACE INVENTORY SERVICES	YES
11.10	APPROVAL OF STATE AND LOCAL GOVERNMENT LEASE-PURCHASE AGREEMENT WITH KONICA MINOLTA PREMIER FINANCE FOR A KONICA MINOLTA BH C651i DIGITAL COPIER	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	Board vote	Scott Dean
1.4	APPROVAL OF AGENDA	6 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
2.1	APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT	5 YES · 1 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Brad Arneson, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: Scott Dean	NO
2.2	APPROVAL OF SUPPLEMENTAL PAY – RYAN COPPLE	3 YES · 2 NOMotion Fails Named votes YES: Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Glenda Williams NO: Brad Arneson, Stella Styers Recused: Gloria Copple	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	Board vote	Scott Dean
1.3	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.3	APPROVAL OF OPEN SESSION AGENDA	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.4	APPROVAL OF MAY 06, 2026, SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.5	APPROVAL OF MAY 12, 2026, REGULAR MEETING MINUTES	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.6	APPROVAL OF MAY 15, 2026, SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.7	APPROVAL OF MAY 26, 2026, SPECIAL MEETING MINUTES	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
7.2	APPROVAL OF APPOINTMENT AND OATH OF OFFICE FOR STUDENT TRUSTEE, GRACE WEHRLI	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.5	APPROVAL OF INSTRUCTOR EQUIVALENCY FOR M. CORONEL JR. AND K. RANGEL	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.10	Consent agenda — 12.1, 12.2, 12.3, 12.4, 12.6, 12.7, 12.8, 12.9 Items included in this single consent vote 12.1 — APPROVAL OF CLINICAL AFFILIATION AGREEMENTS FOR NURSING AND ALLIED HEALTH PROGRAMS 12.2 — APPROVAL OF CURRICULUM ITEMS 12.3 — APPROVAL OF VOLUNTEERS FOR ACADEMIC YEAR 2026-2027 12.4 — APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT - JUNE 2026 12.6 — APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH HUBBE INC. FOR SIS HUBBE STUDENT INFORMATION SYSTEM SERVICES 12.7 — APPROVAL OF HUBSPOT CUSTOMER RELATIONSHIP MANAGEMENT (CRM) PILOT FOR THE GED PROGRAM 12.8 — APPROVAL OF SERVICE AGREEMENT AMENDMENT WITH DILIGENT CORPORATION FOR DILIGENT COMMUNITY PLATFORM SERVICES 12.9 — APPROVAL OF AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO CONSULTANT CONTRACT WITH THERESA BECKER	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.1	APPROVAL OF RESOLUTION NO. 06.09.26-13.1 ORDERING A CONSOLIDATED GOVERNING BOARD MEMBER BIENNIAL ELECTION, SPECIFICATIONS OF THE ELECTION ORDER, AND REQUEST FOR CONSOLIDATION	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.2	APPROVAL OF RESOLUTION NO. 06.09.26-13.2 SUPPORTING THE PURSUIT OF A COMMUNITY ENHANCEMENT COLLABORATIVE GRANT FOR A MICRO BUSINESS CENTER	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.3	RATIFICATION OF EMPLOYMENT AGREEMENTS FOR INTERIM SUPERINTENDENT/PRESIDENT	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.4	APPOINTMENT/APPROVAL OF SECRETARY TO THE BOARD OF TRUSTEES, ED KNUDSON	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.5	APPROVAL OF AUTHORIZED AGENTS AND RCOE CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURES FOR PVCCD	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.6	APPROVAL OF 2026-2027 TENTATIVE BUDGET	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.7	APPROVAL OF FY2028-FY2032 FIVE-YEAR CAPITAL OUTLAY PLAN	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.8	INSTITUTIONAL SELF-EVALUATION REPORT (ISER) – SECOND READ AND APPROVAL	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.9	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH THE INDUSTRIAL EMERGENCY COUNCIL (IEC) FOR FIRE SCIENCE INSTRUCTIONAL SERVICES	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.10	APPROVAL OF PURCHASE OF EMERGENCY MEDICAL TECHNICIAN (EMT) AMBULANCE SIMULATOR	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.11	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT REGARDING PVC FACULTY PARTICIPATING IN THE CREDIT FOR PRIOR LEARNING (CPL) INITIATIVE	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.12	APPROVAL OF OPEN EDUCATIONAL RESOURCES (OER) PROJECT MEMORANDUMS OF AGREEMENT	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.13	APPROVAL OF MEMORANDUM OF AGREEMENT FOR EXTENDED WORK YEAR FOR PVC NON- INSTRUCTIONAL FACULTY	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.14	APPROVAL OF THE 2026–2029 EQUAL EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITY (EEO) PLAN	4 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed Recused: Scott Dean	RECUSED
13.15	APPROVAL OF AMENDMENT NO. 1 TO THE LAW ENFORCEMENT SERVICES AGREEMENT WITH THE CITY OF BLYTHE FOR A CAMPUS TACTICAL OFFICER	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.16	AUTHORIZATION FOR THE INTERIM SUPERINTENDENT/PRESIDENT TO ISSUE A REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS (RFP) FOR SECOND LEGAL COUNSEL SERVICES	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
13.17	APPROVAL OF SUPERINTENDENT/PRESIDENT SEARCH PROFILE	5 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES

Agenda item	Item / motion	Board vote	Scott Dean
1.3	APPROVAL OF CLOSED SESSION AGENDA	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.3	APPROVAL OF OPEN SESSION AGENDA	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
4.4	APPROVAL OF APRIL 14, 2026, REGULAR MEETING MINUTES	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
11.3	Consent agenda — 11.1, 11.2 Items included in this single consent vote 11.1 — APPROVAL OF PERSONNEL ACTIONS REPORT - MAY 2026 11.2 — APPROVAL OF CURRICULUM ITEMS	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.1	CSEA COLLECTIVE BARGAINING AGREEMENT FOR 2024-2027	6 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed Recused: Scott Dean	RECUSED
12.2	ADOPTION OF PVCCD's INITIAL PROPOSAL TO CSEA CHAPTER 180 FOR NEGOTIATIONS REOPENERS	6 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed Recused: Scott Dean	RECUSED
12.3	APPROVAL OF EXTENSION OF AGREEMENT WITH FERRILLI FOR FLEXPERT COLLEAGUE CONSULTING SERVICES	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.4	APPROVAL OF AGREEMENT WITH CIRCLEIN, INCORPORATED FOR STUDENT SUCCESS PLATFORM SERVICES	6 YES · 1 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: Scott Dean	NO
12.5	APPROVAL OF COMPENSATION FOR ACTING SUPERINTENDENT/PRESIDENT	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.6	APPROVAL OF AUTHORIZED AGENTS AND RCOE CERTIFICATION OF SIGNATURES FOR PVCCD	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.8	SECOND READ AND APPROVAL OF BOARD POLICY	7 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Angel Ramirez, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed	YES
12.9	APPROVAL OF ABSENCE FOR TRUSTEE ANGEL RAMIREZ - APRIL 14, 2026	6 YES · 0 NOMotion Carries Named votes YES: Gloria Copple, Jon McNeil, Scott Dean, Brad Arneson, Stella Styers, Glenda Williams NO: None listed Abstained: Angel Ramirez	YES

Agenda items.Votes explained.

CircleIn Agreement

Revised/New Management Job Descriptions.

Ger Xiong and Irma Gonzalez Employment Contracts

My YES and NO votes.

The Board’s collective votes.